Malaysia - Singapore - Indonesia - Brunei
for film & entertainment industry


Sabtu, 13 Ogos 2011

Isu Larangan Baca Al Qur'an guna pembesar suara : Setiap Fatwa mesti berasas logik!', Prof Datuk Dr Abdul Shukor Husin'

Ketika isu 'larangan membaca Al-Qur'an guna pembesar suara' yang dikeluarkan Jawatankuasa Fatwa Negeri Pulau Pinang itu baru-baru ini, nyata menimbulkan kontroversi dikalangan umat islam di Malaysia. Larangan keras yang dikeluarkan Jawatankuasa Fatwa Negeri Pulau Pinang (JHEAIPP) itu sedikit sebanyak menimbulkan polimek dan menjadi isu perbahasan di sana-sini. Dari surat yang dikeluarkan, Jawatankuasa itu memutuskan semua surau dan masjid di Pulau Pinang tidak dibenarkan memperdengarkan bacaan ayat suci Al-Qur'an menggunakan pembesar suara atas alasan 'menganggu ketenteraman masyarakat sekitar yang sedang tidur di waktu Subuh'. Kenyataan itu dibalas oleh Pengerusi Majlis Fatwa Kebangsaan Malaysia, Prof Datuk Dr. Abd Shukor Husin. Menurutnya, setiap fatwa atau larangan yang dikeluarkan berkaitan isu tersebut perlu dikaji sedalam-dalamnya, memandangkan ia topik yang amat sensitif dan ditakuti akan meruntuhkan penyatuan umat islam di Malaysia.

Hamir Mahamud, Pengerusi Kariah Masjid Padang Menora menunjukkan surat yang dikeluarkan JHEAIPP tentang larangan membaca Al-Qur'an guna pembesar suara

Tambahnya lagi, setiap apa jua keputusan yang ingin dibuat Jawatankuasa Fatwa Negeri, perlulah berasaskan logik mengikut budi bicara dan disesuaikan mengikut tempat, persekitaran dan suasana masyarakat. Ini bermakna, setiap fatwa yang dikeluarkan perlu dirujuk bersama mufti di negeri lain, kerana dibimbangi akan menjadi asas hukum kepada larangan di negeri-negeri lain..

Read more for any details of issue..

Komen Amy Ikram:-

'setiap keputusan perlulah berlandaskan hukum islam dan dilaksanakan mengikut kesesuaian tempat. Jika ia diputuskan tanpa perbincangan dengan Mufti atau masyarakat islam di sekeliling, ini bermakna keputusan yang di ambil itu akan menyinggung sensitiviti masyarakat islam. Ini bermakna, sekiranya larangan membaca Al Qur'an menggunakan pembesar suara itu menjadi sah, maka ia seolah-olah memperkecilkan ayat suci Al Qur'an dan bagi saya tujuan masjid atau surau memperdengarkan bacaan ayat suci Al Qur'an itu di waktu subuh ( guna pembesar suara) adalah untuk mengejutkan masyarakat islam di waktu subuh atau waktu sahur ( di bulan ramadan), selain azan subuh untuk mengajak masyarat islam di kawasan itu menunaikan solat subuh. Jadi, isu ini perlu dikaji sedalam-dalamnya oleh Majlis Fatwa Kebangsaan, kerana amat dibimbangi akan meruntuhkan institusi agama islam itu sendiri. Jangan kerana larangan ini dikuatkuasakan, dikhuatiri juga satu hari nanti azan Subuh tidak dibenarkan diperdengarkan di Pulau Pinang yang rata majoritinya bukan beragama islam. Mahukah kita melihat Pulau Pinang menjadi negeri bukan islam?. Wallahuallam'.

Tepuk dada tanya selera..

9 comments :

info yang bagus. Takut2 lepas ni azan pun xleh guna pembesar suare lak.ISh3.

Watak Kartun Di zombi Kg.Pisang Kan!!!

DR MOHD ASRI ZAINUL ABIDIN – Saya Menyokong Keputusan S.S Mufti Pulau Pinang


http://drmaza.com/home/?p=1546#more-1546

Zaman nabi dulu tak ada pembesar suara. Harap maklum.

Kalau seorang Muslim itu dah berniat untuk menunaikan solat, hatta tak ada masjid berdekatan pun, solat itu akan dikerjakannya jua.

Sekiranya kawasan itu majoritinya ramai bukan islam.. Bermakna larangan tersebut adalah amat wajar?. Adakah betul Dr?.




The " Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque "
( a.k.a. " Masjid Bulat " )
in Petaling Jaya (PJ) district,
should SERIOUSLY consider,
to stop playing
Qur'anic recitation MP3's,
on the loud-speaker system
(for approximately
a quarter of an hour;
by 4 times a day),
prior to the ' Call to Prayer '
( ' Adhaan ' ) ·


Just do a Quick Search,
on the Internet,
about the Mosque,
& the following search items
WILL appear :


" Masjid Bulat PJ bising "
" Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque is noisy "
" Masjid Tun Abdul Aziz PJ bising "
" Masjid Tun Abdul Aziz bising "
" Masjid Bulat bising "



- - -


[Q # 1] What special ' authority '
do They ( ' the management ' )
think They have,
that They can FORCE
every man, woman & child
(regard-less of Creed)
in the surrounding vicinity,
to listen to Qur'anic recitations,
coming from Their own mouths ?


[Q # 2] Shouldn't Qur'anic recitation
be an ' act of worship '
by an individual Muslim;
& NOT a source of public ' nuisance '
to the surrounding communities ?


- - -



Numerous Qur'anic verses &
Prophetic narrations can be found,
reminding the Muslims,
AGAINST un-justly treatments
to his / her neighbors.


Please, stop depriving Us,
of Our in-disputable RIGHTS,
to enjoy some
peace & tranquility,
in the comfort & luxury
of Our OWN homes.


Just a " soft reminder " to You.


Sincerely,

– Thy Dis-concerted Neighbor ·


.
.
.



- - -


THE NAADZIR ·


UP-DATE [ 06 / 06 / 2016 ] :


The details for the
in-famous ' Naadzir '
( Arabic for
" The Main Administrator " )
of MTAA
( Masjid Tun Abdul Aziz
@ Masjid Bulat ) ;
who FORCES His Neighbors
to listen to Qur'anic recitations
– from the same Portion ,
mind You –
for 15 minutes , 4 times
every-day ·


( in order of Name , Public capacity ,
Role , Social Media account )



# # # # #



01] Mr. Mohd Yakub @ Zulkifli
bin Mohd Yusoff ·


Director ,
Academy of Islamic Studies ,
Universiti Malaya ( UM )

Director ,
Center of Qur'anic Research ( CQR )

Naadzir ( Leader ) ,
Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque


– AUTHORIZES the broad-casts
of Qur'anic recitation ,
PRIOR to the
Call to Prayer



@ facebook.com/hafid.ismail.35



# # # # #





The following Individuals
are responsible behind the
" REPETITIVE , DISRUPTIVE ,
REPULSIVE , & UN-WANTED
pattern of behavior "
exhibited by the Mosque ,

( i.e. Masjid Tun Abdul Aziz, PJ @
Masjid Bulat, PJ )

BEFORE the broad-cast
of Adhaan.


Since these People
BROAD-CAST Themselves
over the ' surrounding ' air
reciting The Noble Qur'an
( via the Mosque
loud-speaker system ) ,
I took the liberty
of EXPOSING Their identities
to the right-minded
Residents of Section 14 PJ.


Doing so,
I firmly believe that
They can no longer
ACT / HIDE
behind a Proxy / Entity
( i.e. the Mosque &
its Subsidiaries )
any-more.


- - -

So , here's the list :

( in order of Name, Public capacity,
Role, Social Media account )


# # # # #


1] Mr. Mohd Yakub @ Zulkifli
bin Mohd Yusoff ·

Director,
Academy of Islamic Studies,
Universiti Malaya ( UM )

Naadzir ( Leader ) ,
Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque


– AUTHORIZES the broad-casts
of Qur'anic recitation,
prior to the
Call to Prayer

@ facebook.com/Centre-of-Quranic-Research-CQR


# # # # #


2] Mr. Muhammad Lukman
bin Ibrahim ·

Lecturer,
Universiti Sains Islam Malaysia
( USIM )

Guest Imaam * ,
Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque


– The voice of
RECORDED
Qur'anic recitation
( 80 % of the time )

@ facebook.com/DrMuhammadLukman


# # # # #


3] Mr. Wan Ainuddin Hilmi
bin Abdullah ·

Imaam * & Mu-adh-dhin * ,
Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque

Qur'anic Recitation Instructor
& Institute Director ,
Institut Pengajian al-Qur'an ( IPAQ )


– The voice of
LIVE & RECORDED
Qur'anic recitation
( 20 % of the time )

@ facebook.com/pages/Wan-Ainuddin-Hilmi-Abdullah



[ * Imaam = One who leads
the Prayers,
in a Mosque

* Mu-adh-dhin = One who issues
the Call to Prayer,
from a Mosque minarets ]


- - -


Realize that what You're doing
is DEFEATING Your Purpose
of calling People to Islam.


To the Muslims,
You prevent Us
from opening the Mus-haf
( Arabic for " Manuscript " )
by Our-selves ,
with Your LOUD
Qur'anic recitation.

To the Non-Muslims,
You confuse Them
with the extra-lengthy noise
BEFORE the Call to Prayer.


You cast the
seed of HATRED, towards Islam ;
& the worst part of it ?
You did so, KNOWING-LY ·


- - -



On a side note,
I leave the Readers
with an INTERESTING fact :


Those 3 said Individuals
are KELANTANESE.



I mean, it just doesn't
make sense.

The late Nik Abdul Aziz
bin Nik Mat
[ Spiritual Leader of the
Pan-Malaysian, Islamic Party
( PAS ) ]
DID support a SPECIFIC Ban,
on the use of
external loud-speakers
of a Mosque,
for the purpose of " Tarhim "
( Qur'anic recitation
before Adhaan ) .



Now, isn't This
a case for Irony ·



.
.
.

.
.
.

The following Individuals
are responsible behind the
" REPETITIVE , DISRUPTIVE ,
REPULSIVE , & UN-WANTED
pattern of behavior " ,
exhibited by the
Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque ,
BEFORE the Call to Prayer :


# 01 ] Mohd Yakub @ Zulkifli
bin Mohd Yusoff

# 02 ] Muhammad Lukman
bin Ibrahim

# 03 ] Wan Ainuddin Hilmi
bin Abdullah


- - -


So much for the
" Religious Freedom " Thing
going on ,
in Petaling Jaya , Selangor ,
Malaysia ·


.
.
.




The " Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque "
( a.k.a. " Masjid Bulat " )
in Petaling Jaya ( PJ ) district,
should SERIOUSLY consider,
to stop playing
Qur'anic recitation MP3's,
on the loud-speaker system
( for approximately
a quarter of an hour ;
by 4 times a day ) ,
prior to the ' Call to Prayer '
( ' Adhaan ' ) ·


The said Mosque
is located
in the state of
Selangor Darul Ehsan,
Malaysia [ MY ] ·


Just do a Quick Search,
on the Internet,
about the Mosque,
& the following search items
WILL appear :


" Masjid Bulat PJ bising "
" Tun Abdul Aziz Mosque is noisy "
" Masjid Tun Abdul Aziz PJ bising "
" Masjid Tun Abdul Aziz bising "
" Masjid Bulat bising "



- - -


[Q # 1] What special ' authority '
do They ( ' the management ' )
think They have,
that They can FORCE
every man, woman & child
( regard-less of Creed )
in the surrounding vicinity,
to listen to Qur'anic recitations,
coming from Their own mouths ?


[Q # 2] Shouldn't Qur'anic recitation
be an ' act of worship '
by an individual Muslim ;
& NOT a source of public ' nuisance '
to the surrounding communities ?


- - -



Numerous Qur'anic verses &
Prophetic narrations can be found,
reminding the Muslims,
AGAINST un-justly treatments
to his / her neighbors.


Please, stop depriving Us,
of Our in-disputable RIGHTS,
to enjoy some
peace & tranquility,
in the comfort & luxury
of Our OWN homes.


Just a " soft reminder " to You.


Sincerely,

– Thy Dis-concerted Neighbor ·


.
.
.